A woman entered, shaking rain from her coat. She carried a book under her arm, but its cover was blank, the spine cracked from being opened too many times. She looked at me the way a proofreader looks at a comma—suspicious, ready to correct.
“You touched it,” she said. Not a question.
I didn’t answer. The shelf behind me was still dark with the pen’s absorption, the bloom of ink spreading like a bruise.
“The pen was never yours to take,” she said. She set her book on the counter, and the pages riffled on their own, stopping at a page that was blank except for a single line: *The sixth man arrives in four minutes.*
“You’re the fifth,” I said.
She smiled, and it was my smile again, but worn thin, as if it had been used too many times. “I was. I wrote the chapter where you stepped into the gap. I thought that would end it. But the book doesn’t end; it just grows another page.” She tapped her book. “This is the copy I wrote. It says I’m the fifth. It says you’re the first. It says the sixth man is coming to erase us both.”
“Who is he?”
She looked past me, at the window. The reflection had stopped writing. It was standing now, facing us, though no one was on the street. Its face was still mine, but the ink was moving—the features shifting, rearranging, becoming someone I had never seen.
“He’s the one who closes the book,” she said. “He writes the final word. And once he writes it, there are no more chapters. No more pages. No more us.”
The clock on the wall—I hadn’t noticed it before—began to tick. Each tick was a word, each word a letter. *T-minus three minutes.*
“You have to finish it first,” she said. “You have to write the last sentence before he does.”
“How?” I asked. “The pen is gone.”
She held out her hand. In her palm was a pen—not the one I had taken, but another, older, the barrel wrapped in leather, the nib stained with something that was not ink. “You were never the first page,” she said. “You were the last one. And I was the first. We’ve been writing each other in circles, but the circle is about to break.”
She pressed the pen into my hand. The moment I touched it, the room tilted, and I saw the man at the desk again—the one from the window—now sitting across from me in the shop, his face blank and waiting. The ink was rising beneath his skin again, but this time it was not forming my features. It was forming a